Another resignation has been submitted at The Messenger as frustrations with internal dynamics continue to plague the start-up.
Senior editor Suzette Lohmeyer, a member of the politics team, announced her resignation effective June 5 in the company’s Slack channel on Wednesday.
This follows the departures of politics editor Gregg Birnbaum and west coast breaking news editor Kristin Bender. The three editors’ decisions to seek opportunities elsewhere reflect concerns raised by several individuals at The Messenger, which was launched on May 15. Bender had resigned just a few days before the launch, citing dissatisfaction with the outlet’s focus on generating content quickly rather than prioritizing original reporting.
Bender expressed her disappointment to The Daily Beast, saying, “I was told that this was going to be long-form journalism and all it was was aggregated content and clickbait, and to me, that’s not journalism.”
Birnbaum’s departure received coverage in The New York Times, which detailed an intense confrontation between Birnbaum and Neetzan Zimmerman, who is responsible for maximizing traffic. According to the Times, Birnbaum quit on the spot after Zimmerman made a dismissive remark, telling Zimmerman to replace him with someone “who doesn’t know what they’re doing so you can tell them what to do.”
In an interview with the Times, Birnbaum commented on the situation, stating, “The rapacious and blind desperate chasing of traffic—by the nonstop gerbil wheel rewriting story after story that has first appeared in other media outlets in the hope that something, anything, will go viral—has been a disappointment to many of the outstanding quality journalists at The Messenger who are trying to focus on meaningful original and distinctive reporting.”
Lohmeyer’s decision to leave is also motivated by similar frustrations, including an emphasis on publishing first and correcting later, as well as Zimmerman’s influence in the newsroom.
This early wave of departures raises concerns about the future of the fledgling operation, despite having media entrepreneur Jimmy Finkelstein at the helm, significant funding, and experienced journalists like Marc Caputo, formerly of NBC News, on board.
The Messenger initially aimed to employ 175 journalists at launch, with expectations of increasing that number to 550 within a year. The New York Times has reported that the company is on track to reach its goal of 175 employees in the coming weeks.